Shop

  • White Cheddar

    Our original white cheddar made using only the finest ingredients found in nature. This cheese has classic cheddar flavor and is creamy and smooth. Affinage: Aged 3-6 months
  • Chipotlé Cheddar

    We take our original white cheddar and add fire roasted chipotlé peppers giving this cheese a mild spice level with a slight smoky finish. Affinage: Aged 3-6 months
  • Sage Cheddar

    White cheddar with an earthy sage finish. A wonderful lingering flavor you won’t soon forget. Affinage: Aged 3-6 months
  • Cabernet Cheddar

    Our classic white cheddar marbled with cabernet wine, this one is addictive!
  • Jalapeño Cheddar

    Classic White cheddar with spicy jalapeño peppers- a wonderfully mild spice level leaving you wanting more. Affinage: Aged 3-6 months
  • Habañero Cheddar

    White cheddar and the spicest habañero peppers. We bring the heat with this one. An excellent spicy finish! Affinage: Aged 3-6 months
  • Dutch-Style Gouda

    Our classic Gouda is creamy, smooth and savory. Everything you want for that perfect melt-y cheese! Affinage: Aged 3-6 months
  • Hickory Smoked Gouda

    Our Dutch-Style Gouda with a smoky twist. Full of flavor! Affinage: Aged 3-6 months
  • Creamy Jack

    Our classic Jack is creamy, smooth and savory. Everything you want for that perfect melt-y cheese! Affinage: Aged 3-6 months
  • Smoked Jack

    Our classic jack with a smoky twist. Full of flavor! Affinage: Aged 3-6 months
  • Garlic Jack

    Creamy, smooth, Jack cheese with a garlic punch. This cheese finishes with a fresh garlic spicy flavor and that wonderful creamy classic jack texture. Affinage: Aged 3-6 months
  • Pepper Jack

    wonderfully smooth Jack with a blend of jalapeño peppers- creamy & spicy! Affinage: Aged 3-6 months
  • Aged Cheddar

    Our original white cheddar, made using only the finest ingredients found in nature, and cellar aged for over 9 months. Award winning sharp, nutty finish. Affinage: Aged 9-18 months
  • White Cheddar Curds

    Our original white Cheddar in its freshest form. These "squeakers" are a wonderful snacking cheese reminiscent of string cheese as a child
  • Bleu

    Vintage Bleu is a recipe from Southern France. It has a mild bleu flavor with a slightly salty finish
  • Cheese of the Month

    A wonderful, seasonal option to mix up your palette. Small batches allow us to make exciting, unique flavors, be sure to grab more than one, these flavors go fast!!
  • Goat Gouda

    Our Dutch Style Gouda made with Goat milk. A tangy twist on our original 500 year old recipe.
  • Smoked Goat Gouda

    The original Gouda, make with goats milk, and smoked with hickory to perfection. A tangy, smoky twist on a Vintage Cheese classic.
  • Old Goat

    Old Goat is a Wheel Aged Goat Milk Cheese that takes 6-9 months to mature. This slightly tangy, deliciously sharp goat cheese is a wonderful addition to any Cheese plate.
  • Tipsy Goat

    Tipsy Goat is a Wheel Aged Goat Milk Cheese, washed in ale and aged 6-9 months. This slightly tangy, deliciously creamy goat cheese pairs well with fresh fruit, nuts and a wonderfully snackable cheese!
  • Sheep Cheddar

    Our original White Cheddar recipe made with Sheep milk.  Creamy classic cheddar flavor with a touch more texture than the original. A great milk base alternative for commodity cheeses.
  • Sweet Sheep

    Sheep Milk Cheddar cheese with Fenugreek seeds throughout.  A creamy, slightly sweet finish with a hint of butterscotch.  Wonderfully unique flavor!
  • Manchego

    A Spanish origin recipe cellar aged 12-18 months.  Buttery, smooth with a salty finish